Miguel Ángel Llopis (Atecyr): Air conditioning must meet the building’s real demand
An efficient air-conditioning system is not necessarily one with the equipment with the best specifications on paper, but rather one that ensures all its components work in harmony with the building’s actual demand, maintaining favourable operating conditions for as many hours as possible. That's according to Miguel Ángel Llopis Gómez, General Secretary of the Spanish Technical Association for Air Conditioning and Refrigeration (Atecyr), who explains the importance of integrating renewable technologies into air conditioning and refrigeration systems.
How important is the integration of renewable technologies in air conditioning and refrigeration installations?
The integration of renewable technologies is a crucial step towards the gradual decarbonisation of buildings, particularly in a sector such as air conditioning, which accounts for a significant proportion of energy consumption. However, the aim should not simply be to incorporate renewable technologies, but to ensure that they are tailored to the building’s real needs and work efficiently with the rest of the system. To this end, it is necessary to analyse factors like the demand profile, operating hours and operating temperatures.
In this context, technologies such as air-source heat pumps, geothermal energy, solar thermal energy and photovoltaic solar energy can be integrated with conventional power generation systems. The overall efficiency will depend, to a large extent, on how this integration is carried out and on the actual operating conditions, not solely on the performance of the technology selected.
That's why the integration of renewable energy sources should be understood as a comprehensive strategy for the generation, distribution, storage, regulation and control of energy, rather than as the implementation of a single renewable energy system in isolation.
What issues or precautions should be taken into account when carrying out this integration?
The first step is not to start by choosing the technology, but rather by analysing the characteristics and requirements of the installation. Before implementing a renewable energy solution, it is necessary to understand the real demands of the building: heating and cooling loads, hourly profiles, supply and return temperatures, simultaneous demand across zones and seasonal variations.
Some of the key aspects that need to be examined include operating temperatures and temperature lift, as these directly affect the performance of certain equipment, particularly heat pumps; the availability of electrical power, particularly when air-source heat pump systems or installations with high electricity demand are incorporated; the available space, orientation and environmental conditions, both for the equipment and for any solar installations; and the noise level of the equipment and any possible sound insulation or acoustic screening measures.
It is also necessary to assess the building’s structural capacity to support new equipment, storage systems or solar installations; the management and control strategy, defining how the various technologies should operate together and which should take priority in each situation; the system’s performance under extreme conditions, both in summer and winter, ensuring that the design is not based solely on average conditions; and the condition and age of the existing equipment, as it is necessary to assess its remaining useful life and determine whether it makes sense to integrate it with the new systems or to consider replacing it.
It is also important to avoid oversizing. Adding more renewable energy capacity does not necessarily mean that the installation will be more efficient. An oversized installation can significantly increase the investment and cause the equipment to operate for many hours outside optimum operating conditions. For air conditioning, it is often more important to correctly size and manage the available energy effectively than simply to install more renewable energy capacity.
How should one determine which technology is best suited to each situation?
There is no single renewable technology that is universally suitable for all installations. The choice must be based on the building’s specific energy requirements. Firstly, we need to determine which requirements need to be met: heating, cooling, domestic hot water or electricity. Next, it is necessary to analyse when these demands occur, for how long and at what temperature levels.
The decision should be based, at the very least, on a combination of four factors: energy demand, available renewable resources, operating temperature and hourly operating profile. Based on this analysis, the various options can be compared using parameters such as SCOP and SEER, COP and EER, seasonal efficiency, renewable fraction, annual electricity consumption, initial investment, maintenance costs and payback period.
Furthermore, the comparison should not be based solely on the nominal performance specified by the manufacturer. A machine may have a very high COP under certain conditions, yet deliver significantly lower performance when its operation is analysed over the course of a whole year under the actual conditions at the installation site. Therefore, the most suitable technology will be the one that best adapts to the building’s demand profile and maintains good performance for as many operating hours as possible.
How does design affect the performance of facilities?
The design has a direct impact on a system’s performance because it determines the conditions under which the equipment will operate for most of its service life; this is particularly true in a hybrid system, where the aim is to use renewable energy for as long as possible. A correctly designed installation should aim to ensure that the equipment operates for as long as possible under favourable conditions and at appropriate partial loads, avoiding both oversizing and excessively short operating cycles.
In a heat pump, for example, operating at the lowest possible heating flow temperature – provided that this is sufficient to meet demand – can significantly improve its efficiency. In certain installations, it may be more efficient to keep the equipment running for longer periods at a moderate supply air temperature than to run it for short periods at very high temperatures. Other key factors include the design of the water and air distribution systems, pressure drops, circuit balancing, insulation, control systems, zoning and the correct selection of emitters.
For this reason, performance should not be analysed solely at the level of the generator, but by considering the installation as a complete system: generation, distribution, output, regulation, storage, control and demand.
Ultimately, an efficient air-conditioning system is not necessarily one that incorporates the equipment with the best specifications on paper, but rather one that ensures all its components work in harmony with the building’s actual demand, maintaining favourable operating conditions for as many hours as possible.